Book Review: Necessary Lies by Diane Chamberlain


Can the best of intentions be enough justifications for taking decisions for someone else? And what if it’s done in an official way?

Set in America Forrester os an idealistic young woman. Fresh out of college, newly married and just starting her new job as a social worker. Her job takes her to Grace County, one of the most impoverished areas, where people most needed help from the authorities. One of the first families that she meets are the Harts. Ivy and Mary Hart are sisters who live with their aging grandmother and Mary’s two-year old son Baby William. Sixteen year old Ivy, an epileptic seems to be the responsible one, the one who seems to be taking care and keeping an eye on Mary, Baby William and her Grandma’s medications. Mary seems intellectually disabled and so does Baby William.

As Jane, gets involved with the Hart family as part of her job, she realizes that she is unable to keep herself from being emotionally involved. She also discovers some shocking facts about the Eugenics program that is ongoing. Women and girls who are seen to be likely to have children and not be in a position to raise the children, are sterilized by the state. Any excuse would work, some are deemed ‘feeble-minded or marginal’, some are labeled, ‘promiscuous’ anything that could be considered an excuse to prevent these impoverished people from having more children. The social workers were responsible for writing up a petition and getting it done. The worst part of the process is that some of the people who are made to undergo the process are not even aware of it, like Mary. She believes that she had an appendix operation after Baby William was born. She dreams of having 5 babies, oblivious to the fact that she can no longer have any more babies.

Jane is soon faced with a decision she doesn’t want to make. A decision she doesn’t feel, that they as social workers, should be making, in the first place. She faces trouble at work for challenging status quo. Her co-workers are annoyed with her stance and also by her refusal to back down.

Jane’s work is not the only area where the waters are tumultuous. Her marriage seems to be in trouble as well. Her new husband, Robert seems to have very different expectations from his wife that he had with his girlfriend. He is not very happy with her job, the fact that she has to go into the homes of people very poor, or even worse, black. He is unhappy with the fact that she chooses to work, he feels that it is demeaning for him to tell people that his wife is working. He wishes she could be happy with volunteering or pick up a job that is more ‘suitable’. Jane, on the other hand, has ideas of her own, aspirations of her own, and it doesn’t help that all of Robert’s friend’s wives seem to have taken an instant dislike to her. Jane is struggling to manage her husband’s expectations and try to do her best for her clients.

Things come to a head when a certain turn of fate changes the course of events drastically. Suddenly, Jane is faced with a situation where she is suddenly all alone and helpless, and yet she is the only one who can save Ivy from the fate that stares at her.

What a impactful book it was! The book transports you back to the time when Eugenics Program was accepted and people saw no harm in it. They never thought twice about the fact that they were taking control of other people’s lives without even checking with them. It is a spine chilling story, fictional, but something that could have/must have happened to so many people in those times. The Eugenics Program was apparently a social program, designed to weed out ‘undesirable’ traits in the human race. Sounds similar to what happened in Germany, doesn’t it? I guess it’s not surprising to read that Eugenics program was inspiration for what happened in Germany. Apparently, this continued in America from the 1920s till the 1970s. It is unbelievable to think that people actually did this and endorsed it.

I would definitely recommend this book. Not the easiest of books to read. Painful, and excruciatingly sad at times. it makes you wish and hope for Ivy and others like Ivy who don’t stand a chance in life. It makes you glad for people like Jane, who fought the system and made it stop. It is a heart-wrenching read, but still a great read. It ends with hope, hope for a future where people will hopefully not treat others less privileged or less able in this way.

A 5/5 book for me. It’s a tought read, but well worth it, if you ask me.

About the author
Award-winning author Diane Chamberlain, was born and raised in Plainfield, New Jersey, and attended Glassboro State University. She also lived for many years in both San Diego and northern Virginia, where she still resides. She is an author of 22 novels. She usually writes about relationships between men and women, parents and children, brothers and sisters, and friends.

This book is available from Amazon(UK) and Flipkart(India).

Book Review: First Love by James Patterson and Emily Raymond

I’ve always enjoyed Patterson’s crime thrillers. Come to think of it, it’s been a while since I read one. A few years back, I discovered his non-crime writing and loved that too. So when I saw this on the library shelf, I had to have it.


Axi Moore is a good girl, living in a nondescript small town, where nothing really happens. She is sixteen, but unlike normal teenagers, she never does anything naughty. She works hard at school, does all the right things, never breaks a curfew.. The works. Suddenly she wants to do something different. Something far far away from the things she does. She wants to run away from home. Living with her alcoholic father isn’t easy and has given her an insight as to what made her mother give up and run away. She wants to leave her existence in K-Falls behind her. And she isn’t running away alone. She has her best friend Robinson with her.

Together they set off on a cross-country trip together that involves stolen cars and bikes, bluffing their way through, getting into trouble with the authorities and visiting places both of them always wanted to. It was turning out to be a trip of a lifetime. Robison and Axi have history together, they are the closest of friends and have been bound together by fate. Axi loves Robinson, but has never been able to tell him. Robinson is also the opposite of Axi, as in he does everything he can to break rules, test his boundaries. Their trip together marks a journey special as can be. Mad, crazy, dangerous, with memories that would stay with them. It takes them both to places they might have never wanted to go. It makes them face up facts that they would have been happy to ignore.

It is book that will have you in tears. It is sweet, painful, heart-breaking, and still makes you smile, makes you wish you could just wave a wand and get things sorted. Their love has been portrayed so well, sensitive, touching.. From the beginning, you can sense the sadness in Axi, something that becomes clear at the end. Which, by the way, is sad and yet so sweet.

I loved the book. I would happily rate it a 4/5. Do read it only if you don’t mind sniffling your way through the book though.

About the Author
James Patterson is a bestselling author of many titles. He is the first author to have #1 new titles simultaneously on The New York Times adult and children’s lists and is the only author to have five new hardcover novels debut at #1 on the list in one year—a record-breaking feat he’s accomplished every year since 2005. To date, James Patterson has had nineteen consecutive #1 New York Times bestselling novels, and holds the New York Times record for most Hardcover Fiction bestselling titles by a single author (63 total), which is also a Guinness World Record.

This book is available from Amazon(UK).

Book Review: Salaam Brick Lane by Tarquin Hall

After reading ‘The Case of the Deadly Butter Chicken’ by Tarquin Hall, I started checking out the other books by the author. The one which caught my eye was not one of the Vish Puri series, but this one- ‘Salaam Brick Lane’. The fact that it was non-fiction, set in London’s East End sounded very interesting.


Tarquin Hall returns to England after 10 years abroad. Returning back he realizes to his dismay that he cannot afford to live in the leafy suburbs of his childhood. He had been priced out of the nicer London areas and the only place he could afford was a tiny, squalid attic, above a Bangladeshi sweatshop in London’s East end – Brick Lane. A place whose reputation precedes it. A place which he hopes is temporary, a place from where he hopes to move from before his Indian born, American fiancee lands in London.

Things don’t quite work as he planned, as most things in life. He ends up staying for a little longer than he had planned to. It was not quite the London he had planned to introduce his fiancee, Anu to. Living on a street filled with drug peddlers and prostitutes peddling their fare, it was not quite the London to write home about. And yet, despite the unsavoury characters and the reputation of the place, Hall discovers people and their stories just as any other place in the world. He discovers the world that immigrants have made their own. Some out of choice, some because they donot have a choice at all.

East End has a history of having been the place where immigrants have settled and have got absorbed into British Socieity. From the Jews to the latest in the line, the Bangladeshis. It was funny to read how some people who had come to Britain as immigrants now consider themselves British and are ready to campaign against the new immigrants. It was interesting to read how the East End has moulded itself over the years and taken over the characteristics of it’s latest inhabitants while absorbing them into a unique but still British Identity.

Hall’s narrative is interesting and non-judgemental and is fascinating read. It has a great set of characters, a lot of variety and their stories bring out a perspective to the East End some of us might have never known about. The life some of the immigrants lead, looked at with suspicion by some, being in a place, they never wished to be in the first place, was an insightful read. For others it was still a life much better than the one they left behind in the countries they came from. He adds in his personal story as well, which just adds to the flavour. His life with his fiancee, who is initially horrified by their surroundings(being mistaken for a prostitute doesn’t help, I’m sure!) but slowly comes to terms with Brick Lane, warts and all. As they chart their lives together, Brick Lane provides a fascinating backdrop in it’s character and colour. An intriguing narration of life as an East Ender by someone as far removed as possible from it, someone who has had a privileged upbringing, in London suburbs which are as different as they can be from London’s East End.

For me, it was full of insights and bits of history, which I found very interesting. An account of London’s immigrant hub, so to speak which seemed to have been the place immigrants have always migrated to. A place which has sheltered them and taken on their idiosyncracies and flavour, transforming into Jew town when the main immigrants were Jews and now, in it’s latest avataar, Banglatown. Who knows what it’s future holds, but whatever it might be, East end promises to be interesting and vibrant.

All in all, a great read. It’s a 4.5/5 from me. I have to say, I enjoyed Hall’s non-fiction a lot more than his fiction(I’ve just read one).

About the Author
About the Author
Tarquin Hall is a British author and journalist who has lived and worked throughout South Asia, the Middle East and Africa. He is the author of The Case of the Missing Servant, dozens of articles, and three works of non-fiction, including the highly acclaimed Salaam Brick Lane, an account of a year spent above a Bangladeshi sweat shop in London’s notorious East End.

This book is available from Amazon(UK) and Flipkart(India).

Book Review: The Sweetest Hallelujah by Elaine Hussey

This another book which jumped at me from a bookshelf in the library. I do seem to come across a lot of acrobatic books these days, I have to say 🙂


It is 1955. Southern America is engulfed in racial problems. Betty Jewel Hughes was once the hottest black jazz singer in Memphis. But when she finds herself pregnant and alone, she gives up her dream of being a star to raise her beautiful daughter, Billie, in Shakerag, Mississippi. Now, ten years later, in 1955, Betty Jewel is dying of cancer and looking for someone to care for Billie when she’s gone. With no one she can count on, Betty Jewel does the unthinkable: she takes out a want ad seeking a loving mother for her daughter.

The advert catches the eye of Cassie Malone, a white woman from the other side of town. Living a different, far more luxurious life than Betty Jewel and Billie, but misfortune and unhappiness dogging her as well. Cassie is still struggling to come to terms with her husband Joe’s death. She goes to a psychiatrist, on her sister-in-law’s suggestion, who suggests that she take up a project. Little does she know that she is about to embark on a project that would change her life. On seeing the ad for a mother, Cassie, who works as a journalist and having covered stories from the other side of town, is immediately interested. Her editor and close friend Ben, is not too keen on Cassie covering stories from there, given the racial tension that is prevalent, but knowing Cassie, is aware that she is not easily deterred.

Cassie discovers more than she would have wanted to. She discovers connections that she wouldn’t have dreamed about, and soon finds herself involved far more than she would have ever imagined, in the lives of Billie, Betty Jewel and her mother Queenie. I wish I could say more, but that would mean giving away more of the story than I should.

A sweet, moving story albeit a little unrealistic. The author portrays emotions beautifully. A child who suddenly realizes that her mother is dying. All she wants is to keep her mother alive, and if that is not possible, to go and find her father who she has been idolizing for long. Billie is an endearing, spunky, determind and strong child but even the strongest of children can get affected deeply when faced with the fact that their mother is dying. Betty Jewel, her mother, harboring a secret for years, having hidden it from the world, now, nearing death, is coming to realize that she might have to reveal the truth, to at least some people. A secret that could potentially be explosive given the racial tension they were going through. Betty’s mother Queenie is another strong character, unfazed by what life deals her. The unlikely friendship that sprung up between Cassie and Betty Jewel was really touching to read, especially since they had all the reasons to stay away from each other. The story was fast paced, rich in detail, kept my interest, till the end. The way it ended, however, was a little difficult to accept, for me. Suddenly, everything just falls in place, which seemed a little difficult to believe given the context. The way things fall into place in a part of the country where racism was rampant and tempers ran high, is a little difficult to believe. Especially since the book builds it up so well, people’s attitudes and prejudices, the violence and the intolerance.. And the ending, where everything just fell in place, perfectly, I have to say was a wee bit disappointing for me. Not that I wanted an unhappy ending, but I wish it was portrayed a wee but more realistically.

All in all, an interesting book, one that gave me a little more insight into America in the 1950s. Books like these show us a slice of culture and how things have slowly changed(for the better over) the decades. I would rate it. 3.5/5.

Just one more thought, the cover picture is rather misleading. Neither Billie nor Cassie fit into the image that is portrayed by the picture. Not that it makes a big difference, but I like covers that have some sort of relevance to the book.

About the Author
Elaine Hussey is a writer, actress and musician who likes to describe herself as “Southern to the bone.” She lives in Mississippi, where her love of blues and admiration for the unsung heroes of her state’s history served as inspiration for The Swe etest Hall elujah . Visit her at

This book is available from Amazon(UK) and Flipkart(India).

Book Review: The Case of the Deadly Butter Chicken by Tarquin Hall

This book was recommended by Smita and Pixie, and luckily for me, I found it in my library, that very day! That never ever happens to me!


I picked it up only to realize that it was the third of a series, but that didn’t retract in any way from the book, I have to say.

Vish Puri is the famous detective, who has been solving mysteries while gobbling up delicacies of all sorts. He is extremely fond of food, butter chicken is one of his favourites, and he tucks in, albeit surreptitiously to avoid his wife when he chances upon a mysterious meeting with two individuals, one of whom ends up dead on the floor as soon as he eats the butter chicken, Puri had just enjoyed. The dead man is the famous Pakistani Cricketer Kamran Khan’s father.

Vish Puri ends up involved in the case, but of course! And eventually solves it with the help of his Mummyji, who despite her son’s pleas refuses to accept that detective work is not for mummies! It’s a fun journey with Vish Puri as he goes about his job, eating his way through situations. The author does an incredible job portraying India, it is as if we are there. His words transport you to the places, the alleyways and the journeys that protagonists embark on. It was all spot on. The mystery was well handled, and the suspense was maintained well.

So would I recommend it? It’s an interesting book, for sure. The story as well as the setting is well etched out. Keeps you engrossed, a complete page turner. I have to say that if I have to choose a favourite character, it would the feisty Mummyji! I absolutely love her! She was so much fun! If the other books feature her as well, I’m definitely picking them up. Some of the things that niggled at me was the use of Indian-English. Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for using the local language, but I felt that in some places, it felt forced, didn’t feel natural. As if the author was trying too hard. Either that or I’m out of touch with India. Might be the latter, if I’m honest.

I wasn’t too taken by the secondary plot of the missing moustaches. The book would have been just as great without it, in my opinion. But these are minor quibbles at most.

I would rate it a 3.5/5.

And before I forget, I found a non-fiction book by the same author which feels like something I would love to read! And what makes it doubly exciting is that I have gotten hold of it too! It’s just waiting to be read, as soon as I finish the one I’m currently on.

About the Author
Tarquin Hall is a British author and journalist who has lived and worked throughout South Asia, the Middle East and Africa. He is the author of The Case of the Missing Servant, dozens of articles, and three works of non-fiction, including the highly acclaimed Salaam Brick Lane, an account of a year spent above a Bangladeshi sweat shop in London’s notorious East End.

This book is available from Amazon(UKand Flipkart(India).

Book Review: Everything and Nothing by Araminta Hall


Some books jump at you from bookshelves. This was one of those. I don’t know what made me pick it up, but I did.

Actually, it was probably these lines on the blurb.

Cupboards were sticky from spilled jam and honey, and the oven smoked when you turned it on because of the fat that had built up over the years. Agatha would never, ever let her future home end up like this. She would never leave it every day like Ruth did. She would never put her trust in strangers.

Ruth and Christian Donaldson are a busy London couple with a life that could be the envy of others. However, their marriage is falling apart, their two children, five year old daughter, Betty, wouldn’t sleep and three year old son Hal. Everything seems to be a mess. Ruth is at her wits end trying to balance work and life. Her guilt over choosing to work surfaces now and again. Until Agatha, or Aggie, their new nanny steps in.

Aggie seems to be an angel in disguise. She seems to have changed their lives ever since she arrived. The kids adore her, she seemedto have taken control over everything in minutes. She seems the answer to all their problems but why is it that Ruth is feeling so uncomfortable. Something isn’t quite right about Agatha. We as readers start to understand what is wrong, while Ruth struggles to figure out in the middle of everything else that is happening in her life.

The blurb calls it a psychological thriller and it certainly fits the bill. It is scary and yet completely believable. People with ordinary lives, dysfunctional at some levels, struggling to make things work out. Agatha, is probably any mum’s worst nightmare. The person you trust with your children can easily be the most dangerous of people. And dangerous in a way that is difficult to come to terms with.

It was an interesting read. An absolute page turner. Ruth and Christian are believable characters, flawed but believable. Agatha was a character who was confusing and as the story progresses, her motivations and her state of mind becomes clearer. The characters are well defined, and story is fast paced and gripping. It grabs you from the start and doesn’t let go till the very end. I would rate it a 4/5.

About the Author

Araminta Hall began her career in journalism as a staff writer on teen magazine Bliss, becoming Health and Beauty editor of New Woman. On her way, she wrote regular features for the Mirror’s Saturday supplement and ghost-wrote the super-model Caprice’s column.

This book is available from Amazon.

Hilawi by Ritu Lalit

Ritu has been someone whose writing I’ve always enjoyed. I have been a silent lurker on her blog, mainly because I don’t have much to add, but I’ve always loved the way she writes. Her books have been on my wish list, but somehow I didn’t end up picking them up when I was in India. But when I found it on Kindle, I went ahead and got it. It then sat on my kindle for ages, because I gravitate towards proper books most of the time. Only during the holidays does the Kindle get to see the light of the day. So this last holiday, I went through all my pending reading on the Kindle.

Now, I have had the not so greatest of experiences with bloggers turning authors.  I haven’t read too many but the ones I did, well, wasn’t as great as I expected.  Once, I came across this blogger who actually asked me if I had read her book, and it was a bit embarrassing because I had, and I did not enjoy it as much as everybody else seems to have done. So I was squirming a bit, hoping to find a way out. I normally do not review books I don’t like, so it got a little awkward for me.

Since then, I try not to mention if I am reading a book of someone I might know. I needn’t have worried, this time.


Gargi(Gigi) and Yaduvir(Vir) Ojha are twins living in London. Despite being twins, they are nothing like each other. Yaduvir, is  calm and mild mannered man, while Gigi is a feisty, young woman. Gigi, Yaduvir and Madhur, Yaduvir’s girlfriend Madhur are inseparable and great pals. Their regular, smooth life is suddenly interrupted when a sudden phone call summons them back to India. As soon as they land in India, they realize that something is very wrong. Their grand-uncle is not just having old age related delusions. Everything that they had taken for granted changed instantaneously. They are apparently, the guardians of ancient shield, Hilawi which is guarded very carefully, because of its sensitive and dangerous nature.

Hilawi is supposed to bring luck and prosperity to those who possess it. That makes it very lucrative to a number of people. The Ojha women are supposed to be true guardians and just like her mother before her, Gigi is the chosen one while Vir is the protector. Things start to change rapidly, not just around them, but within them as well.  Before they know it, they are plunged into the unknown, and they have to use all their wits to work their way out. Not only do they have to safeguard Hilawi, they also have to outwit several others who are out to get their hands on it. They have to figure out for themselves who is evil and who is not.

A taut story line, well-etched characters and a fast paced narrative makes this book  a  quick and interesting read. The mythological story of Hilawi was very interesting. It had me hooked from the beginning to the end. It is fantasy thriller and I have to say, I love the author’s imagination.

I especially loved the way it ended. So much so, that I wish it had a sequel. So would I recommend it, of course! I would give it a 4/5.

About the Author

Ritu Lalit is a successful author of three books, A Bowlful of Butterflies, Hilawi, and Chakra, Chronicles of Witch Way. She also has a very popular blog. She lives in the National Capital Region, with her two sons, daughter-in-law, three dogs, a cat, fishes and a water turtle.

This book is available on Amazon and Flipkart.

Shakespeare’s Mistress by Karen Harper

This was originally published as Mistress Shakespeare. The edition I picked up was titled Shakespeare’s Mistress.  During Shakespeare’s times, the word Mistress was meant to mean Mrs.

shakespeare's mistress

I seem to be going through an Elizabethan phase, I’ve been picking up so many books from this era.

The fact that Shakespeare had married Anne Hathaway is a well known fact. What is not so well-known is that there is two days before Shakespeare married Anne Hathaway, there exists a permission for him to marry Anne Whateley of Temple Grafton, a place close to Stratford-Upon-Avon. Two days later, some family friends of Anne Hathaway seem to have placed a bond for Shakespeare to marry Anne Hathaway Scholars have generally dismissed it as a clerical error but what if it weren’t? What if, Anne Whateley was a real person. What if, she was in reality Shakespeare’s muse and secret love. The person he wrote those sonnets for. What if Shakespeare was forced to marry Anne Hathaway because she became pregnant, while being in love with someone else all through?

Karen Harper uses that bit of fact and weaves a story around it. The story is told by Anne Whateley, from the time they met, as children to the time of Shakespeare’s death. It’s a believable tale. One can imagine how things happened, and how their love stood the test of time. Harper’s words transport you into that time. You are right there, with Anne as she tests her boundaries, takes up challenges and lives her life on her own terms. Anne Whateley comes across as a strong person, although it does make you wonder why she accepts the her role in Shakespeare’s life.  All she really wanted was to be known as Mistress Shakespeare, but all her life, she hides away, in London, supporting Shakespeare in any way she can, all the while, knowing that for the world, Mistress Shakespeare is another Anne, in Stratford.

Another book where it is difficult to figure out where the fact ends and fiction begins. Harper has taken facts and beautifully interwoven them with fiction. She has also, very clearly, used pieces from Shakespeare’s plays in the book, so very naturally, that it looks entirely possible that Anne Whateley was indeed the person, that Harper has built up for us. It had me turning to Google to find out more. A book that makes you wonder if the historians have actually missed something that was staring at their faces.

A wonderful read, if you like historical fiction.

I give it a 4/5.

About the Author

Karen Harper is a is a former college English instructor (The Ohio State University) and high school literature and writing teacher. Karen loves the British Isles, where her Scottish and English roots run deep, and where she has set many of her historical Tudor-era mysteries and her historical novels about real and dynamic British women. Karen’s books have been published in many foreign languages and she won the Mary Higgins Clark Award for 2005.

This book is available at Amazon and Flipkart(India).

The Almond Tree by Michelle Cohen Corasanti

I’ve had the unfortunate luck of never really getting a truly mind blowing book when I get a review request. When Michelle Cohen Corasanti emailed me asking me if I would like to review her book, I was intrigued by the story and immediately agreed.


Ichmad Hamid was a gifted young Palestinian boy living in a Palestinian village controlled by the Israeli Army in the 1950s.  The smallest of things are enough to get in trouble with the Army. Living in a constant fear of landmines, and the atrocities committed the army, Ichmid and his family are not the most secure of families. Ichmid, is very gifted, extremely intelligent and sharp, he excels at his studies, but is forced to drop school and go to work when his father gets thrown into the prison on the suspicion of aiding terrorists. Ichmid and his younger brother Abbas, 12 and 11 year olds, have no option but to go to work and earn a living. They make very little, but they can’t do without it either. They have no home, and no permit to build one, and are forced to live in a tent, in all sorts of weather and conditions. The work they did, managed to keep them from starving, but also handed out more misfortunes for the family. Torn by responsibility and guilt, his only support was his father, who refused to see evil in anybody. His father’s constant support through letters kept Ichmid’s faith. There came an opportunity for him to get a scholarship at the Hebrew University, and it was his father who backed him and gave him the courage to stand up for himself. His mother and his brother Abbas, felt that it was a betrayal on his part to go to an Israeli University and work with the Jews. They were the people who were responsible for the condition of their lives, after all.

Ichmid persevered, balancing out his life, keeping his family as his first responsibility sometimes having to take difficult decisions. While Ichmid managed to make a life for himself, despite all the misfortunes and cruelty that he and his family were dealt with, the book makes you reflect on those who get sucked into the situation, with no way out, like his brother Abbas. Ichmid follows his father’s advice of not letting hatred consume him, while Abbas, went the other way. Abbas, of course, had been dealt with a more difficult hand though, so it is understandable to see his frustration and his unhappiness with his brother’s decision to work and be friends with their oppressors. So easy for two brothers to be brought up in similar circumstances but end up in completely different areas in life.

It is a heart-breaking read. One that will leave you sad, and upset, that there is so much of injustice in the world. So many people are fighting for a life, a simple life, a life without fear, the  things we take for granted. While this book was specifically about the Israel-Palestine conflict, it could resonate in any of the conflict ridden parts of the world. It also opened my eyes to what is happening in Palestine. The living conditions, the constant fear that they live with, with no real future for their children.. things we can’t even imagine.

The story starts with a bang, and the author manages to maintain that tempo. Reading about the Hamid family’s life and misfortunes makes you realize how many lives are caught in political conflicts which they have nothing to do with. All that most people want is a happy, comfortable and secure life, which sadly remains a dream in so many conflict hit parts of the world.

While not an easy read, it was a total page turner. I just couldn’t put it down. The only reason I took a couple of days to read it was because I had a migraine, but even that couldn’t stop me from picking up the book and reading. Despite the mindless tragedies, and the sadness, it is a book that ends with hope. A hope that one day we will see a conflict free world.

The subject was gripping, as I already mentioned enough times already, I also loved the characters. Each of them, easy to identify with. Even when you might not agree with their methods, you understand where they are coming from. You feel Ichmid’s guilt and sense of responsibility, as well as the feeling of being torn between what he needs to do and what his family thinks. Abbas’ anger and frustration, Baba’s gentle strength which holds Ichmid strong. Nora, I loved Nora! Let me just stop here and say that it is a book worth the read.

I give it a 4.5/5. I would love to read more from the author.

About the Author

Michelle Cohen Corasanti is a Jewish American woman with a BA from Hebrew University in Jerusalem and a MA from Harvard University, both in Middle Eastern Studies. She is also a lawyer trained in international and human rights law. She has lived in France, Spain, Egypt, and England, and spent seven years living in Israel. She currently lives in New York with her family. The Almond Tree is her first book.

This book is available on Amazon and Flipkart(India).

Thank you, Michelle Cohen Corasanti for the review copy.

Dreams of Joy by Lisa See.

Having loved Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, I had to grab Dreams of Joy as soon as I saw it.


Joy is the 19-year-old daughter of Chinese Immigrants in America. Her world has just been turned upside down. She has just learnt that the her mother was actually her aunt, and the person she calls her aunt was actually her birth mother. Her father, or the person she knew as her father has just passed away. The people who she trusted the most, seemed to have harbored secrets from her, all her life.  The world as she knew it has just ended.

Confused and driven by her idea of China, Joy grabs some money her mother has set aside and runs away to China. Enamoured by the idea of New China, completely taken in by everything she read, she wants to head to China and be part of the building of New China. Undeterred by everybody who warns her that the reality is far from what she has heard, she is convinced that Chairman Mao is the saviour that China is waiting for. She also has a personal motive, she wants to find her birth father, the famous artist Z. G. Li.

So off she goes, full of optimism and excitement, convinced that she is going to be part of something historic. For her, Socialism seemed to be the answer to all evils.  Reaching China, she realizes how different things are from the life she left behind, but far from pining away for the luxuries and life that she left behind, she throws herself into her new life. She sees only the positives. Every hardship , is taken as a blessing.

Back in America, when her mother Pearl realizes that her daughter has reached China, there was only one thing for her to do. Follow Joy to China. She knew she had to go there and ensure that her daughter is safe, and bring her back, if she can. Pearl and Joy’s separate journeys meet in China. Pearl goes through trails of her own, face demons from her past, make peace with conflicting emotions within her, try to learn the new language that she needs to speak, for Joy to hear her. She realizes that she needs to build bridges and trust with her daughter, all over again. Pearl comes to realize that all she can do is support her daughter, no matter how much it hurts her to see the decisions her daughter takes, and wait and hope that Joy understands why her mother is so worried about her.

Both Joy and Pearl live through tragic and difficult circumstances in China. China during the ‘Great Leap Forward’ is portrayed and it is heart breaking to read some of the stuff. The schemes that were launched, the cruelty that people endured, and the class difference that still existed in the society despite what socialism promised them. There are times when I wished Joy wouldn’t be so blind to what was really going on. But for a young person, full of a purpose, the excitement, the joy of being part of something so big, it might be easy to not see the whole picture. I wish I could say more without giving away the whole story, but I can’t. So I will just say, read it. It is a book worth reading.

As I read it, I realized that it was the second part of a series, but it was quite easy to connect the dots and get the story. Lisa See has obviously done a lot of research to write this book. She brings Shanghai and the countryside where Joy lived to life. We live the life that they lived while we read the book. All the characters are beautifully defined, and very believable. The ending ties up very well with the rest of the book. I am definitely going to find ‘Shanghai Girls’, the prequel to this book, even though I know what happened in the end, it would be an interesting read, I think. Again a historical fiction, which brought to life, an era, in a country that I knew little about.

I would give it a 4/5.

About the Author

Lisa See is a Chinese-American author. Her books include Snow Flower and the Secret Fan (2005), Dragon Bones, and On Gold Mountain. She was named the 2001 National Woman of the Year, by the Organization of Chinese American Women. She lives in Los Angeles.

This book is available from Amazon and Flipkart(India).